This web app uses cookies to compile statistic information of our users visits. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. If you wish you may change your preference or read about cookies

January 9, 2024, vizologi

Step-by-Step Guide to Idea Screening Stages

Do you have lots of business ideas but find it hard to choose the best one? Idea screening can help. This guide will take you through the process of evaluating, refining, and prioritizing your ideas. You’ll finish with a clear idea of what makes a winning idea, and be ready to move forward in making it a reality.

Understanding Idea Screening

What Does Screening Ideas Mean?

When screening ideas, it’s important to use specific criteria like meeting business goals and customer needs. Research methods, like surveys and focus groups, can help evaluate and filter ideas.

Concept development, testing, and business analysis are essential in the screening process. They help identify promising product concepts and assess their potential. Concept testing gathers customer feedback on product concepts, while business analysis ensures ideas align with the organization’s strategy and goals.

The Big Why: Reasons to Filter Your Ideas

Idea screening is a crucial step in product development. It helps to filter out the best ideas and save time and money. By analyzing and choosing carefully, businesses can avoid costly failures and focus on ideas with high success potential. Techniques like SWOT and PESTEL analysis provide a better understanding of market trends, risks, and opportunities. This process also ensures stakeholder buy-in and expert feedback, leading to the discovery of ideas that resonate with respondents.

Getting Started with Idea Selection

Come Up with Many Ideas

To come up with many ideas effectively, one strategy is to encourage brainstorming sessions involving various stakeholders. This can include idea generation workshops, surveys, and suggestion boxes to collect ideas from employees, customers, and other relevant parties. Another approach involves using various ideation techniques such as SCAMPER, Mind Mapping, or the 5 Whys method to stimulate creative thinking and generate a diverse set of ideas.

Research plays an important role in both generating and filtering ideas during the idea screening process. This can involve conducting qualitative and quantitative research to gather customer feedback, understand market trends, and evaluate the feasibility and potential success of different ideas. By conducting thorough research, businesses can ensure that the ideas being considered are aligned with customer needs and preferences, market demands, and the company’s strategic objectives.

This research-backed approach enables businesses to make informed decisions and focus on developing ideas that have the greatest potential for success.

Pick the Good Ones: Setting Up Criteria

When selecting good ideas, it’s important to consider various factors. These include market demand, feasibility, profitability, and alignment with business objectives.

Qualitative research provides insights into consumer preferences, behavior, and attitudes. This helps in developing criteria that match customer expectations.

Quantitative research helps gather statistical data and measurable metrics. This, in turn, assists in creating specific, quantifiable criteria.

SWOT Analysis and PESTEL Analysis are tools that can be used to assess the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats of an idea. They also help in evaluating its political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal implications.

The Bridges framework (BRIDGeS) is a multi-context analysis tool for ideation and decision-making. It allows businesses to evaluate product concepts from different perspectives and effectively set up criteria for picking good ideas.

Do Your Homework: Researching Your Ideas

It’s important to do your homework and research your ideas before making final decisions. This ensures that the product development process aligns with business objectives and customer expectations.

Research helps evaluate potential ideas using set criteria, data, or scoring models. It also helps identify ideas with a high probability of success, saving time and money, and ultimately avoiding failure.

When researching ideas, conducting in-depth research and using multi-context analysis tools like the Bridges framework , SWOT Analysis, and PESTEL analysis can be effective.

Concept development and concept testing can help in the process of idea screening by evaluating ideas against set criteria and discovering which ones resonate most with respondents. Getting stakeholder buy-in, input from experts, and using a dedicated Idea Screening (XM) solution to evaluate ideas are also critical elements in this process.

Talk to People: Qualitative Research

Qualitative research is important in the idea screening process. It helps understand consumer preferences, behaviors, and needs. Talking to people provides in-depth information about their experiences, pain points, and desires. This helps evaluate product ideas. Effective strategies for qualitative research include in-depth interviews, focus groups, and observational studies. These methods allow for rich, detailed data collection.

They help businesses understand consumer sentiment and find potential areas for innovation in product development.

Look at the Numbers: Quantitative Research

Quantitative research is important in the idea screening process. It helps to identify and evaluate potential ideas. Businesses can use surveys and statistical data to measure consumer preferences, market trends, and the potential success of new product concepts. This approach provides an objective and measurable way to screen ideas. Surveys collect quantitative data from a large sample size, while data analytics and statistical modeling help to interpret and analyze the data.

These methods ultimately narrow down the pool of ideas to those with the highest likelihood of success, aligning with business objectives and meeting customer expectations.

Digging Deeper into Idea Screening

Make Your Ideas Grow: Concept Development

Concept development is important for making ideas grow and evolve. It involves transforming initial concepts into viable, marketable products. Idea screening ensures that only the most promising and feasible product concepts move forward. It involves evaluating ideas against specific criteria, conducting qualitative and quantitative research, and using tools such as the Bridges framework, SWOT Analysis, and PESTEL analysis.

These strategies help in examining and assessing the viability of new product ideas, ultimately aiding in the effective development and successful launch of new products.

Checking Your Idea: Concept Testing

Concept testing is very important in product development. It helps determine if an idea is feasible and likely to succeed. By doing concept testing, businesses can get feedback from potential customers and test the idea before moving forward.

There are different ways to do concept testing, such as using quantitative and qualitative research. Tools like SWOT Analysis and PESTEL Analysis can also help assess new product ideas. Gathering feedback and data from the target audience is crucial during concept testing. It provides insights into customer expectations and preferences, which helps in developing products that meet business objectives and appeal to the market.

Concept testing also helps businesses identify ideas with a high chance of success, which saves time and resources. It also prevents potential failures in the product development process.

Will It Work? Business Analysis

“Will It Work? Business Analysis” evaluates potential ideas using specific criteria, data, or scoring models. It helps determine if an idea aligns with business objectives, customer expectations, and its probability of success. Key considerations for business analysis in idea screening include evaluating ideas against set criteria, conducting qualitative and quantitative research, getting stakeholder buy-in, and seeking input from experts.

Dedicated Idea Screening solutions can aid in the evaluation of ideas and selecting promising product concepts. SWOT Analysis and PESTEL analysis can also be used to assess the viability of new product ideas.

Try It Out: Test Marketing

Test marketing serves the purpose of evaluating the viability and potential success of product ideas in the idea screening process. This allows companies to gain insight into how potential consumers will respond to a new product or service, identify any potential issues, and make informed decisions about which ideas to move forward with.

Additionally, test marketing can provide valuable data and feedback to help make final decisions on which ideas to pursue further and which ones to discard. Some strategies and tools that can aid in conducting effective test marketing include SWOT analysis, PESTEL analysis, and the Bridges framework , all of which offer simple yet effective methods for evaluating and analyzing the market potential of new product ideas.

Final Decisions on Ideas

The Last Check: Final Screening

Businesses must carefully consider the final screening process for idea selection in new product development. This includes evaluating ideas against specific criteria, conducting qualitative and quantitative research, and testing product concepts. It’s crucial to involve stakeholders and experts for effective evaluation. Avoiding common pitfalls, like personal bias or ignoring customer needs, is also important.

These elements are essential for the success of the final screening stage in the idea selection process.

Help Along the Way: Tools and Strategies

Frameworks That Help Pick Ideas

There are different frameworks to help with idea selection. One example is the Bridges framework. It’s a tool for analyzing ideas from different perspectives.

Another helpful tool is the SWOT Analysis, which examines ideas, and the PESTEL analysis, which assesses new product concepts.

There are also specific Idea Screening solutions that evaluate ideas to find the most appealing ones.

These tools are important for streamlining the idea screening process and finding successful ideas that match business goals and customer needs.

SWOT: Finding Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats

SWOT analysis is a helpful tool for evaluating ideas and business opportunities. It looks at strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. Strengths and weaknesses focus on internal factors, like resources and limitations, while opportunities and threats look at external factors, like market trends and competition.

For example, a strength could be a strong brand reputation, while a weakness could be limited financial resources. Opportunities might include emerging market trends, and threats could involve increased competition or changes in regulations.

SWOT analysis helps identify areas for improvement and growth by assessing strengths and opportunities, as well as potential challenges and risks by considering weaknesses and threats. For instance, if a business wants to expand its market share, it would use its strengths and opportunities, while also addressing weaknesses and mitigating threats.

PESTEL: Checking the Big Picture

PESTEL analysis is a helpful tool for understanding the external environment when screening new ideas. It involves assessing Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Environmental, and Legal factors. Businesses should consider government regulations, economic trends, social attitudes, technological advancements, environmental concerns, and legal requirements.

This analysis identifies potential opportunities and threats, guiding the idea screening process and ensuring alignment with the external environment. Effective strategies for using PESTEL analysis include thorough research, considering multiple perspectives, and informing decision-making. By following these steps, businesses can gain insights into external factors and make informed decisions.

Software That Can Help

Software can help with idea screening. There are options like dedicated Idea Screening solutions. These tools evaluate potential ideas using set criteria, data, or scoring models. They help identify ideas that align with business objectives and customer expectations.

In the concept testing stage, software assists by providing tools for conducting research. These solutions offer features for evaluating ideas against specific criteria and conducting in-depth research using tools like the Bridges framework.

Additionally, idea screening software can use techniques like SWOT Analysis and PESTEL analysis to assess the viability of new product ideas, providing businesses with comprehensive insights and data-driven decision-making support.

Doing Idea Screening Right

Advice for Great Idea Screening

During the idea screening process, it’s essential to use specific criteria to evaluate and select ideas. Criteria can include market demand, feasibility, and potential return on investment.

Qualitative research methods, like focus groups or interviews, offer valuable insights into customer preferences. Quantitative research, such as surveys or statistical analysis, is used to gather data and validate the potential success of ideas.

When screening ideas, it’s important to avoid common pitfalls like confirmation bias, where only ideas that align with preconceived notions are selected, and groupthink, where group members conform to consensus opinions without critical evaluation. Also, refrain from over-relying on past successes, as this can hinder the discovery of innovative and potentially impactful ideas.

By carefully considering these aspects, businesses can effectively screen and evaluate ideas to ensure that the most promising concepts are pursued in the product development process.

Vizologi is a revolutionary AI-generated business strategy tool that offers its users access to advanced features to create and refine start-up ideas quickly.
It generates limitless business ideas, gains insights on markets and competitors, and automates business plan creation.


+100 Business Book Summaries

We've distilled the wisdom of influential business books for you.

Zero to One by Peter Thiel.
The Infinite Game by Simon Sinek.
Blue Ocean Strategy by W. Chan.


A generative AI business strategy tool to create business plans in 1 minute

FREE 7 days trial ‐ Get started in seconds

Try it free