This web app uses cookies to compile statistic information of our users visits. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. If you wish you may change your preference or read about cookies

January 9, 2024, vizologi

Models for Idea Screening: What Works Best

Idea screening is a crucial step in the innovation process. It helps companies figure out which concepts have the most potential for success. There are different models for idea screening, each with its own strengths and limitations.

In this article, we will explore these models and analyze which ones work best in helping companies identify promising ideas. Understanding these models’ strengths and weaknesses helps businesses make informed decisions about which ideas to pursue.

Understanding Idea Screening

The post talks about how to screen ideas. It includes evaluating ideas against criteria and doing research. It introduces the BRIDGeS framework for idea screening and talks about the importance of looking at a product concept from all angles. It also mentions other idea screening techniques like SWOT analysis and PESTEL analysis. It suggests using visual aids and storytelling to present screening results effectively.

Also, involving stakeholders and experts to give feedback is important for successful idea screening.

When to Use Idea Screening

When thinking about whether or not to use idea screening, there are several important factors to consider. The most crucial factors are the feasibility and potential success of the new ideas.

Idea screening helps with decision-making for new concepts or projects by filtering out weak or unviable ideas. This ensures that only the most promising and potentially successful ideas are pursued.

Idea screening is particularly useful when there is a large number of initial ideas that need to be narrowed down, or when there are limited resources and time available for development.

Businesses can focus their efforts and resources on ideas with the highest likelihood of success by conducting idea screening. This ultimately leads to greater efficiency and success in the product development process.

The Process of Filtering Ideas

Step 1: Coming Up with Lots of Ideas

One way to generate lots of ideas is through brainstorming. In these sessions, people freely share their thoughts and suggestions. This helps to get a diverse range of ideas and consider different perspectives.

Techniques like mind mapping and word association can also help to stimulate creativity and generate many ideas. Generating numerous ideas in the early stages of the process is important because it increases the likelihood of finding innovative and effective solutions.

By exploring a wide range of ideas, individuals can identify unique and promising concepts. This can meet business objectives and customer expectations. Thoroughly exploring possibilities ultimately improves the chances of selecting the most viable and successful ideas for further development and testing.

Step 2: Checking Ideas Against Rules

During the second step of idea screening, new ideas are checked against key rules or criteria. These include feasibility, market potential, compatibility with the company’s resources, and alignment with overall business objectives.

Evaluating ideas against these rules helps determine their viability. It identifies which concepts have the potential for success and which ones may face challenges.

This allows the organization to focus efforts and resources on the most promising ideas, increasing the likelihood of a successful product launch.

Once the screening process is complete, the results can be presented to stakeholders through clear and concise reports. These reports outline the findings and recommendations.

Stakeholders can use this information to make informed decisions about which ideas to advance to the next stage of development.

Step 3: Researching Ideas More

Researching ideas in the idea screening process can be done in various effective ways. These include conducting qualitative and quantitative research, involving stakeholders and experts, and using frameworks like the BRIDGeS model.

SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) and PESTEL (Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Environmental, Legal) analyses are valuable tools for studying and evaluating ideas. They help identify internal and external factors that may impact the success of a product concept and provide a comprehensive understanding of its potential viability.

Once the idea screening process is complete, the results can be showcased through visual aids like charts, graphs, and detailed reports, as well as presentations to key decision-makers. Interactive workshops and prototype demonstrations can also be used to demonstrate the most promising product concepts in a tangible and engaging manner.

Step 4: Making Your Idea Even Better

To improve and refine the initial idea, one can utilize techniques such as SWOT analysis and PESTEL analysis to gain a deeper understanding of the idea’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats, and its political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal aspects. These strategies can help enhance the feasibility and effectiveness of the idea by identifying potential challenges and opportunities that may affect its success.

Gathering feedback and input from stakeholders and experts is also crucial in further developing and strengthening the idea. This can be achieved through qualitative and quantitative research, as well as involving potential customers in concept development and testing to ensure that the idea aligns with their needs and expectations. The incorporation of the BRIDGeS framework for idea screening is recommended to assess the idea comprehensively and ensure that all aspects are thoroughly examined for potential improvement.

Frameworks that Help Decide on Ideas

How to Know if Your Idea Will Work

To determine if an idea will work, specific criteria should be used. These include market demand, feasibility, uniqueness, and potential for profitability.

SWOT analysis can be employed to evaluate the potential success of an idea. This is done by identifying its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. This helps to assess its competitive advantage and potential challenges.

PESTEL analysis plays a crucial role in determining if an idea will be successful. It does this by assessing external factors. These include political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal influences. This provides a comprehensive understanding of the idea’s potential impact within its operating environment.

Moreover, the BRIDGeS framework is suggested as an effective method for idea screening. This framework focuses on multiple factors that contribute to the success of a product concept. It ensures a more thorough and holistic evaluation.

Using SWOT to Look at Ideas

The SWOT analysis is a useful tool for evaluating ideas. It helps identify strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats for each idea. This helps companies make better decisions about which ideas to pursue.

For example, a company might find that one idea has strong market potential but lacks resources for implementation. This can guide them to seek more resources or pursue a different idea.

The SWOT analysis encourages a thorough examination of each concept, considering internal and external factors. It helps identify the best ideas and eliminate less feasible ones by highlighting factors that may impact their success.

For instance, a company may realize that one idea is threatened by competitors while another idea is well-positioned to capitalize on a growing market trend. This can lead to the advancement of the latter and the elimination of the former.

The PESTEL Way to Study Ideas

The PESTEL way to study ideas has six key components: Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Environmental, and Legal. This framework helps evaluate and analyze ideas by providing a comprehensive view of external factors impacting a product concept’s success.

By considering political conditions, economic factors, social trends, technological advancements, environmental aspects, and legal regulations, the PESTEL framework offers a holistic assessment of potential opportunities and threats associated with a new idea. It can complement other idea screening frameworks, providing a broader perspective on external factors affecting an idea. When used alongside techniques like SWOT analysis, it enhances the overall idea screening process by offering deeper insights into the market and competitive landscape.

Cool Ways to Show Your Screening Results

Dig’s Three Main Things for Picking Ideas

1. Evaluating ideas against specific criteria

  • This helps ensure that only the most promising product concepts are advanced for testing.

2. Conducting qualitative and quantitative research

  • Businesses can gather valuable insights into customer preferences and market trends, informing the decision-making process for advancing product concepts.

3. Concept development and testing

  • Critical for filtering and selecting the most viable product concepts, thus increasing the likelihood of success for new products.

By applying these three main things to the idea screening process, businesses can effectively filter and select the most viable product concepts, saving time and resources in the long run. This increases the potential for long-term success in the market.

Vizologi is a revolutionary AI-generated business strategy tool that offers its users access to advanced features to create and refine start-up ideas quickly.
It generates limitless business ideas, gains insights on markets and competitors, and automates business plan creation.


+100 Business Book Summaries

We've distilled the wisdom of influential business books for you.

Zero to One by Peter Thiel.
The Infinite Game by Simon Sinek.
Blue Ocean Strategy by W. Chan.


A generative AI business strategy tool to create business plans in 1 minute

FREE 7 days trial ‐ Get started in seconds

Try it free